Multi-Storey Car Park
PECKHAM MULTI STOREY
- 1 2017
- 1.1 1st June 2017 consultation extended
- 1.2 28 April 2017 end of consultation
- 1.3 April 2017 Media coverage
- 1.4 March 2017 Planning status
- 1.5 Peckham Multi Storey building, place, uses
- 2 ARCHIVE 2013-2016
- 2.1 Planning status of the Peckham Multi Storey
- 2.2 Future of the building
- 2.3 The next five years from 2015
- 2.4 Campaign to protect Peckham's rooftop views
- 2.5 MultiStory Orchestra
- 2.6 Other material
1st June 2017 consultation extended
28 April 2017 end of consultation
We registered over 5,200 letters to the Council through the Peckham Vision wixsite webportal: https://peckhamvision.wixsite.com/peckhammultistorey, We now await the Council's response to the request for the change in the NSP's proposal that the Plan should be revised to provide for a review as the Planning Inspector recommended, before a decision for comprehensive redevelopment is taken.
April 2017 Media coverage
Evening Standard Online 16 April 2017
Evening Standard headline: Campaigners battle to save popular Peckhamplex cinema from redevelopment
"A letter, drafted by Peckham Vision, to Councillor Mark Williams reads: “The multi storey building on the site has shown that it has significant ability to create jobs, small businesses and important social and community spaces. With demolition of the existing building, and redevelopment which might take several years, this embedded social value would be lost. This option would impose high environmental and social costs. This potential should not be discounted without the research that the PNAAP Planning Inspector recommended in 2013/14."
”Cllr Williams said: "...the multi storey car park is a centre for the arts and culture. Bold Tendencies is well established, and once Peckham Levels join them, we’ll gain a real insight into how the building adapts to a more intensive use than the previous poorly-used car park. We have recently signed new leases with all of the current occupants of the car park building, and at the same time we are consulting on the long term plan for the future of the site – which we think should include a strong cultural, creative and artistic presence. We have received a lot of consultation responses already and want to continue hearing from local residents and visitors about what they think should happen here.”
Peckham Vision comment: The BIG question is whether the Council will go ahead with a risky significant disruption through demolition and redevelopment without a review of the options first.
Southwark News 13 April 2017
Southwark news headline: Peckhamplex owners respond to council’s plan to demolish cinema and carpark
“Local campaigners are calling on residents to support the cinema and existing businesses by responding to the public consultation. Eileen Conn of community group Peckham Vision said: “The Peckham Multi-storey building has played a big role in Peckham for several years and is continuing to do this with the opening of Peckham Levels later this year. The council is asking what people think of their plan. It is really important for everyone who cares about the building and its role in opening up great opportunities for developing social, cultural and economic life in Peckham, to get their views in now.”
Letters to the Council now over 4,000 12th April
The automated letter for people to send to the Council to 'Have their say' has now been sent to the council over 4,000 times within the first 11 days since it was launched.
LondonLive TV news 11th April 2017
London Live TV 11th April 2017 : "There are fears for the future of a popular independent cinema in South East London. For more than a decade PeckhamPlex has operated from a multi-storey car park. But under plans to redevelop the area, the site will be demolished. A community group called Peckham Vision say that's not what they want. Our reporter Alison Earle has been speaking to the campaigners."
Time Out 7th April 2017
"Save the PeckhamPlex! Is one of London's favourite cinemas facing closure? The PeckhamPlex is an institution – and not just for the £5 cheap seats. This beloved blockbuster emporium feels like a proper, old-school cinema, with its sticky floors, extensive pick 'n' mix selection and young couples fumbling in the back row. It's a regular winner in reader-voted Time Out polls for a reason: it's part of Peckham's cultural landscape. But now the multiplex could be under threat. In 2013, plans to redevelop the area called for the Moncrieff Street multi-storey car park – the building that also houses the PeckhamPlex – to be knocked down."
March 2017 Planning status
New Southwark Plan (NSP)
The ‘Preferred Options’ stage of the New Southwark Plan (NSP) is out for consultation until 7th July 2017 (extended from previous deadline of 28th April 2017). Further information here. There are 4 sites in Peckham that the NSP proposes for development. Information here. The ‘Cinema and multi storey car park’ (NSP56) is one of them. This proposal is for ‘comprehensive redevelopment’ of the (NSP56) site.
- See NSP Pages 211-213 in http://www.peckhamvision.org/wiki/images/2/27/NSP_AV%26SA_-_Peckham.pdf
This would need demolition of the multi storey building, and the end of the uses by Bold Tendencies, Franks Cafe, Peckham Levels and PeckhamPlex cinema. But it is premature (see below) to take the final decision about the long term future of the site now in the NSP.
- If you agree with the Inspector that further work needs to be done, you can USE THE LETTER HERE to send in your comments to the Council by 28th April. Or write your own email and send direct to email@example.com and firstname.lastname@example.org quoting NSP56.
What the Planning Inspector said 2013/14
At the PNAAP Public Hearings in July 2013, and in his report in 2014, the Government Planning Inspector said that he was not satisfied that the Council’s plan for redevelopment of the Peckham Multi-Storey building
- “has been adequately justified by the evidence base. I conclude that the PNAAP is unsound in this regard and that the Council has much work to do in order to finalise a properly substantiated proposal for this site. The pending preparation of the borough-wide New Southwark Plan provides an opportunity for this to be tackled.”
The Inspector’s report recommended that the multi-storey car park site be removed from PNAAP designation for further research: see report pages 28-29, paragraphs 127 - 134. The site was removed, and the PNAAP was formally approved in 2014.
What has happened since then?
The Council extended the temporary leases for Bold Tendencies and Franks Café until 2021/2022. They also listened to local proposals by Peckham Vision and Copeland Park that in the meantime the empty levels should be reused to test other potential uses. They leased the empty levels to MakeShift company for Peckham Levels which is opening in September 2017 until 2022. So there will be more useful information emerging over the next few years about the practical issues of reusing the building in the longer term, and also scope for exploring wider potential uses. It is premature to take the final decision about the future of the building before using the experience and information being generated by Peckham Levels to examine the practicalities and costs and benefits of reusing the building, and investigating its potential, as the Inspector said should be done.
What should happen next?
The Council should discuss with local stakeholders the brief for a sound examination of the potential longer term uses of the building with costs and benefits comparing comprehensive redevelopment with reuse and refurbishment. This would comply with the Inspector's recommendation and make use of the forthcoming experience of Peckham Levels, in addition to the continuing uses by Bold Tendencies and Franks Café, and PeckhamPlex. There is ample time for this work before the end of the temporary leases by 2023. The PeckhamPlex cinema has a very long lease which means they would have to be relocated or their lease CPO’d (compulsory purchased) after 2023. There is no certainty that PeckhamPlex could survive the redevelopment of this site. The review of the reuse option would be able to examine the sound ways to retain PeckhamPlex in Central Rye Lane in both the redevelopment and reuse options.
Why is the building important?
The building has become home for important social and cultural activities since it stopped many years ago being the Sainsbury’s food store it was originally built for in 1983.
- The PeckhamPlex cinema in the front half of the building, originally occupied by the store, is a well loved cinema catering for a wide range of local needs at very reasonable prices. The Council agrees that this cinema needs to remain in Peckham: “Councillor Mark Williams, Southwark Council’s cabinet member for regeneration and new homes, said: “Peckhamplex is an important social and cultural amenity and the council intends to ensure that it continues to thrive. As the car park building remains an area of possible redevelopment in the next few years, the council is committed to working with Peckhamplex to identify potential options for relocation within the central Peckham area.” Peckhamplex Director John Reiss, along with Simone Brown, Marianne Gary and Rakesh Makhecha were recently honoured by the Mayor of Southwark for their services to the borough. Mr Reiss said: “Peckhamplex values its loyal, local clients and the increasing number of customers coming from across London who can enjoy a wide range of the latest film releases at affordable prices.”
The issue at this stage is that there is no certainty that a satisfactory relocation will be possible. The strength of feeling locally for the cinema means that there should be no unnecessary risk taken with its future. This is another very strong reason for ensuring that the decision to schedule this site for comprehensive redevelopment is not taken in the NSP (New Southwark Plan) but after the public review of the building’s long term potential.
- The three top levels of the multi storey car park at the back have become a destination each summer for local people and visitors from all over London and further afield for Bold Tendencies' exhibitions and cultural programmes and performances.
- The roof-top experience, with the wide expansive spaces and view with Franks Café as a focal point, has become a significant draw for many visitors.
- The Multi Storey building will increase its contribution to the local community and economy because of the creation of Peckham Levels opening from September 2017 for five years providing new workspaces, and creative and leisure facilities, for local small businesses and the local public.
All these uses have contributed to the emergence and growth of new creative and cultural sectors in Peckham’s local economy, and created new business opportunities for supplying these new economic sectors. The building already plays a significant role in the social, cultural and economic life of Peckham and is part of Peckham's expanding role as a destination for London as a whole and further afield. Before a final decision on the long term future of the building, it is right to review the impact of the new Peckham Levels in addition to the existing uses, and to explore the future long term potential of reusing the building compared with demolishing it and starting again.
Peckham Multi Storey building, place, uses
Model of cinema & car park building
This scale model was built by Paloma Gormley, the designer builder of Franks Café. It is now on display with permission in Peckham Vision studio in the Bussey building.
The building and the place
The building is a very strong and resilient structure. It would be quite likely to survive a cataclysmic event as imagined in Nick Cobb’s dystopian model. It is striking and unusual with a highly expressive structure quite unlike the repetitive and monolithic form usually found in such car parks. See the photos. The building is set back from Rye Lane fronted by Moncrieff Place which is the forecourt to the PeckhamPlex cinema. The path to the car park goes along the south side between the building and the railway viaduct. The PNAAP envisages the space between the rail viaducts, currently occupied by a scaffold yard, to be opened up to the town centre. This would include opening up the arches in the north viaduct to the town centre from Rye Lane (expected within the next few years). This would transform the path between the multi storey building and the railway, linking also to the connections with the two green paths proposals for the Peckham Coal Line and the Bussey path.
The PeckhamPlex cinema occupies the front part of the building. This was built in 1983 for Sainsbury's supermarket, with the remainder of the building a multi-storey car park for the supermarket. The top three levels have been used since 2008 each summer from July to September by Bold Tendencies, a large scale sculpture park, and Frank's Café, a bar and restaurant. Each year further site-specific visual and performing arts have developed as part of the Bold Tendencies programme. The empty levels below have rarely been used, with town centre car parking using only the lower levels. Seven of the levels below Bold Tendencies are being converted by Peckham Levels for work studios, co-working spaces and for community, social and leisure uses.
Planning status of the Peckham Multi Storey
Council planning weblinks have all changed. It will take some time to restore all the links. If the link on this page you want is part of the PNAAP process and is broken you can find the adopted Peckham & Nunhead Area Action Plan (PNAAP) here
The Council says you can also access it from the Area Action Plans page by clicking on the relevant link, along with the supporting and background documents here: http://www.southwark.gov.uk/info/200211/area_action_plans which can be accessed from the main planning policy page on the left hand side.
The Council owns the Cinema/Multi Storey Car Park and still plans to sell it for redevelopment, in spite of the huge success of Bold Tendencies, Frank’s Café and the Peckham Plex cinema showing its potential as a permanent cultural centre. However the PNAAP Planning Inspector rejected that plan, and said “… that the Council has much work to do in order to finalise a properly substantiated proposal for this site. The pending preparation of the borough-wide New Southwark Plan provides an opportunity for this to be tackled.” Since then Peckham Vision created a public discussion about the long term future of the building. This included suggestions for the interim use of the empty levels in the car park, which has led to the initiative to create Peckham Levels, opening in August 2017 for 5 years. What is still needed is a review of the alternative uses of the building for the long term and their viability to create as the Inspector said "a fully substantiated proposal for this site". The New Southwark Plan is likely to be published for consultation again in February 2017. This will include the Council's plans for the long term future of the site. These should include how they plan to carry out the work the Inspector said should be done.
See the overall story about the site in these three display panels (click on each image to enlarge):
click on each image to enlarge
Meanwhile the Council has now responded to the last few year's community calls to explore alternative uses for the empty car park. The Council asked (August 2015) for bids (prospectus here) to use the empty levels as part of managing the whole building for the next 5 years - see here. This was good news and a great way to explore other uses for the short term and for the long term. Sadly, the local community was not involved in the drafting of the brief for the bids, nor the bidders encouraged to find out what the local community might want to contribute. So far local discussions have come up with a variety of potential new uses in the empty levels including cultural event spaces, workshop spaces for crafts, makers and recycling, food growing, film and location studios, retail shops, small business and community pop-ups, and temporary accommodation units linked with work units. Now the contract has been let to Pop Community Ltd (see more below), we hope that they will have a collaborative process to finding out what the wider community wants to use the empty levels for. See Peckham Vision's statement in the letter to the press after the announcement of the contract.
Long Term plans
THIS SECTION IS BEING UPDATED (March 2017)
But these new Council plans are just on a temporary basis. They say they are just for the next five years before the site is up for redevelopment. This means demolishing the cinema part of the building as well as the car park parts now showing their significant potential. So the big question now is to develop the long term vision and plan for saving the building for alternative long term uses, and convince the Council that is the right future for that site. We can do that by encouraging Pop Community to think about a variety of potential uses to meet local needs and also to test their feasibility and viability, as well as to engage with local councillors about the longer term potential.
Please email your ward councillors about this so they know there is widespread support for long term adaptation/conversion, and also for protecting the views while these discussions are under way. It would be very short-sighted to save the building for the long term and lose the spectacular views. Find your ward councillors here.
After representations by local people at the PNAAP Public Hearings in July 2013, the Government Planning Inspector said that he was not satisfied that the Council’s plan for redevelopment of the Peckham Multi-Storey building “has been adequately justified by the evidence base. I conclude that the PNAAP is unsound in this regard and that the Council has much work to do in order to finalise a properly substantiated proposal for this site. The pending preparation of the borough-wide New Southwark Plan provides an opportunity for this to be tackled.” The Inspector’s report recommended that the multi-storey car park site be removed from PNAAP designation for further research: see report pages 28-29, paragraphs 127 - 134. The site was removed, and the PNAAP was formally approved in 2014.
There now needs to be a thorough reassessment of the ways the building could be adapted or converted for other uses, without demolition. It is now part of our local history. There is a strong case for its conservation and adaptation. However, in the Council's draft of the New Southwark Plan, (under consultation until last March 2015), the cinema/multi storey car park site was simply listed in the schedule of development sites without any indication that the Inspector recommended further research into its capacity for adaptation or conversion for other uses. The Council has said since then that while there are no immediate plans to sell the site for redevelopment, it will be redeveloped in a few years. They have listened to local proposals that in the meantime the empty levels should be reused, and the new Peckham Levels is opening for this in Spring 2017. While this is welcome, it is not the ‘properly substantiated proposal’ for the long term use of the site that the Inspector said there should be. The Council will be consulting in early 2017 on its Preferred Options for development sites across the borough. A key issue for Peckham is what it will say about the Council's preferred option for the Peckham Multi Storey building and site, and how they are developing the substantiated proposal the Inspector said should be produced. The Council have so far said they want to sell it for redevelopment. To comply with the Inspector's recommendations, the NSP site designation must require the Council to produce a report for consultation about the future of the site, including the potential for reuse of the existing building for the long term.
Future of the building
The striking architecture of the building, with the spectacular views and the resounding success of the summer cultural events, together with the successful independent cinema and the potential new uses, add up to a strong case for reusing the whole building all year round permanently. See above sections for details of the planning status, and other issues. We have been campaigning to encourage the Council and everyone to think widely and laterally about the way it could be adapted and reused in the long term.
Prompted by our campaign, the Council accepted in November 2015 Pop Community's bid to run the multi storey car park part to utilise the empty levels of the building for alternative uses over the next five years, maintaining the existing alternative businesses on the top three levels. But the Council still says their plan is to sell the site for redevelopment after that. It is essential that the organisation chosen has the right proposals to enable a wide variety of workspaces to operate there in the next five years to get a good demonstration of the long term potential.
The bidders were not encouraged to talk to the community and no community involvement in the process was allowed. on 6th November 2015:Pop Community Ltd, the team behind Pop Brixton, it was announced had been selected to act as interim manager of the council’s multi-storey car park in Peckham for the next five years. This is the company's statement about their plans. As we, like all other local community interests, had been allowed no voice in this process, we can only hope that they as the successful bidder will run the building over the next five years to enable the spaces to be used in the best way to demonstrate the building's potential for future long term uses.
February 2016 update Peckham Levels are holding another two consultation events on their plans considering the feedback, ideas and input at the first consultations last week. They will be showing updated plans on 18th and 20th February. It’s worth going to understand what they are planning, and to give them comments. There is still time for them to consider feedback before seeking planning permission.
See plans displayed 4+6 Feb 2016
July 2016 update
Peckham Levels have secured planning permission for their plans for converting the empty levels for use over the next 5 years. The long term future of the building remains to be decided in the context of the New Southwark Plan. So far the Council has talked just about selling for demolition and redevelopment. The Council will be consulting in early 2017 on the designation of sites across the borough including this site. Already community action has removed the site from the PNAAP for further work to explore its potential for long term uses. The current Peckham Levels project is now showing that it is possible to repurpose the building for uses in tune with the changing Peckham economy. Now we have to give time for that to be demonstrated for the long term and not just as an interim use. Read here the background to the planning issues and the current planning process.
The next five years from 2015
This is information from Pop Community who have been awarded the contract to run the empty levels in the car park for the next 5 years:
""Peckham Levels will spread across 6 levels of the carpark, converting the currently empty space into a mixture of environments designed to inspire and support a new community of artists, makers and creative entrepreneurs.
- Levels 1 and 2 will be dedicated to artists studios and a range of shared workshop spaces with print facilities, materials workshops and photography studios.
- Levels 3 and 4 will offer coworking space, flexible offices and shared media facilities for young creative businesses, including recording studios and editing suites.
- Levels 5 and 6 will become a multi-purpose community and creative hub, with event space, dedicated gallery and performance areas, retail outlets for our members to promote their work, and a food and drink offering hosting local independent traders.""
- Press Release about the project.
- Website: http://www.peckhamlevels.org/
- Give your ideas: http://www.peckhamlevels.org/#!share-your-ideas/s7ao6
Campaign to protect Peckham's rooftop views
The Council wants to encourage development of a 20 storey building in front of the view from Frank’s Café, Bold Tendencies and the Bussey Building. A local campaign, by the Peckham Planning Network, to protect Peckham’s rooftop views has been launched. SIGN THE PETITION HERE During the summer many thousands of people flock to Peckham town centre to enjoy the open spaces that have been created on the roofs of iconic buildings by Frank's Café, Bold Tendencies and the Bussey Building, bringing a new buzz and opportunities for economic activities to the town centre. The view over London is a major draw. But that view may be threatened if a planned 20-storey building is built on the nearby Aylesham Centre/Morrison’s site. The petition asks Southwark Council to put on hold any plans for a tall building on the Aylesham Centre site, until the future of the multi-storey car park building, where Frank's Café, Bold Tendencies and the PeckhamPlex cinema operate, has been discussed and agreed. The on-line petition can be signed here. A copy of the paper petition to collect signatures in neighbourhoods can be downloaded here.
Petitions have also been available to be signed at Barry's Café beside Peckham Rye station, in Rye Lane in Khan's Bargain Store and in front of Elaine's card stall outside the cinema opposite MacDonalds. The campaign has also been present on Rye Lane outside MacDonalds and in Rye Lane in front of the Cinema with local people available to discuss the issues and with petitions to sign. The petition was presented 7th February 2015 to the Community Council, with over 4,500 signatures at that time. The Deputation explained how the view from the rooftop relates to the future of the multi storey building and research about alternative uses was explained. Deputation making its statement. There were no questions from the Councillors but one made a statement. This was in favour of discussion with the Peckham Planning Network about the future of the cinema/car park building. See here for some first pictures and comments on the meeting, deputation speaks, petition presented.The campaign is continuing while the long term future of the building is not settled.
The rooftop views - articles, quotes and pictures section under construction
- stylised city skyline as seen from Peckham: http://instagram.com/p/rvHimRKNX8/
- "Feast your eyes on Central London from afar - you can see the Gherkin, the London Eye and the Shard among the city skyline." Conde Nast Traveler http://bit.ly/1zZ4zK2
- campaign to protect the rooftop views: https://www.facebook.com/protectpeckhamsview
[photos to upload]
When the multi story orchestra is playing you can hear it from the platform of Peckham Rye Station. This multi-storey car park in Peckham was built in 1983 to serve Sainsbury’s supermarket. After less than 10 years, Sainsbury’s moved to its present site on Dog Kennel Hill. The cinema was built to occupy the space of the former supermarket and the car park at the back was significantly under used.
In 2008, the Hannah Barry Gallery, located in the Copeland Park site which was saved from demolition by the Peckham Vision campaign, started the Bold Tendencies project, on the top three floors of the car park, as an out door sculpture park. Franks Café was developed to serve the visitors to the Sculpture Park, and a programme of events developed each year to accompany the exhibitions and Café. The first orchestral performance was in 2011. It was created by the Multi Story Orchestra.
Kate Whitley and Chris the founders of the orchestra say: “2014 is the fourth year we've been in the Peckham car park. For the young professional musicians who make up the Multi-Story Orchestra it has almost stopped being a novelty! Hopefully a new generation of classical music performers, supporters, and audience members, will take on the idea, and classical music may be able to spring up in new spaces and new contexts, and continue to be a living breathing part of our contemporary culture. From the concrete expanse of level seven there are spectacular views across London, you get a powerful feeling of being detached from the rest of the world, despite being right in the middle of busy Peckham. Traditional venues for classical music are churches and concert halls. Audiences tend to dress, act, even clap, in particular ways. Classical music is often seen as something that people come to later in life, and younger audiences are in short supply. We wanted to bring classical music out of the concert hall and explore other, more exciting ways for this music to be heard and understood. By escaping the spaces that classical music normally inhabits it becomes possible to escape from its traditional associations, and potentially attract audiences who might find those associations - but not the music - alienating. The set-up is designed to create a focused listening environment, but people are free to wander. That said, there are inevitable acoustic limitations with being in a car park! During rehearsals, the space is a bit of a nightmare - an unwieldy echo creates a problematic lack of concentration of sound. The arrival of an audience essentially provides a wall around the orchestra, enclosing the sound and creating what can be a very intimate performance space. Although people are free to wander, get a drink from the bar, take a look at the view, or hang around at the back of the crowd and dip in and out of watching the performance if they like, the set-up is designed to create a focused listening environment. The audience provides a wall around the orchestra, enclosing the sound."
31st August 2013 - Brahms Symphony No1 at Bold Tendencies, MSCP
Rumours in the town centre were circulating that the Council had sold the building to developers. Southwark News (16 June 2014) reported this was not true.
Other background is on PV Planning page: http://www.peckhamvision.org/wiki/Planning. Particularly:
- 3.5 23rd July to 1st August 2013 PNAAP Public Hearings - http://www.peckhamvision.org/wiki/Planning#23rd_July_to_1st_August_2013_PNAAP_Public_Hearings
- 3.2 Inspector’s proposed PNAAP modifications & the creative industries - http://www.peckhamvision.org/wiki/Planning#Inspector.E2.80.99s_proposed_PNAAP_modifications_.26_the_creative_industries
- 2.3 April 2014 Planning issues in central Rye Lane http://www.peckhamvision.org/wiki/Planning#April_2014_Planning_issues_in_central_Rye_Lane
Adaptation of large buildings
This section collects examples of adaptations of similar large buildings. Please send links about any others to email@example.com
Example of reusing and adapting a car park: The Remakery in Brixton.
The University of Tokyo student workshop in 2011 looked at the capacity to adapt six town centre buildings, one of which was a multi-storey car park: http://adaptablefutures.com/2012/03/converting-parking-structures/
A preliminary study, by Pollard Thomas Edwards Architects, in conjunction with an MSc course at the Bartlett in May 2011, focused on reuse as housing. https://www.bartlett.ucl.ac.uk/planning/programmes/postgraduate/mscdiploma-urban-regeneration/attachments/cerise-road
17th July 2013 - Bold Tendencies
28th July 2013 - London Contemporary Music Festival at Bold Tendencies